Entries have typically run between 2500 and 4500 words, but it seems like 3500-4000 has been the sweet spot for a lot of the stronger submissions. Anything longer becomes an act of diminishing returns; stories have seemed to waver as the writer tries to pull it all together past that 5000 mark.
I’ve also found that the shorter ones, the flash fiction-length (500-1500 words) entries have a harder time proving themselves. The best of them can capture a feeling, a moment in time, but with the shorter submissions I’ve read I’ve found it harder to gain purchase, so to speak.
This is not to say that anyone should be padding out their shorter stories or chopping up their longer ones. If they’re good, they’re good, and most readers will recognize that.
Genre writing seems pretty uncommon, as you might expect from the slush pile of a review focusing on literary fiction. Out of the hundred or so I’ve read recently, only one has been in the realm of fantasy. Only four or five would be considered horror. There’s been a few crime entries, a few sci-fi, and absolutely zero westerns, though I guess that isn’t too strange. I frown to see how few nonfiction entries there are, but that’s just me.
Keep up the great writing, everyone!